PSA Card Grading
Drop off your cards and we handle everything — packaging, shipping, tracking, and return. All service tiers available. Buy offers and consignment options on your graded returns.
All PSA tiers available
$500 insurance included
Payment upfront at drop-off
SlabTracker CSV on request
Buy offers & consignment available
PSA Standard Grading
Price per card · Times are PSA business-day estimates and may vary
Value Bulk
$29.99
per card
~95 bus. days
Max declared $500
Value
$37.99
per card
~75 bus. days
Max declared $500
Value Plus
$54.99
per card
~45 bus. days
Max declared $500
Value Max
$69.99
per card
~35 bus. days
Max declared $1,000
Regular
$84.99
per card
~25 bus. days
Max declared $1,500
Express
$154.00
per card
~15 bus. days
Max declared $2,500
Full Insurance
Super Express
$304.00
per card
~7 bus. days
Max declared $5,000
Premium Imaging
Walk-Through
$604.00
per card
~7 bus. days
Max declared $10,000
Premium Imaging
PSA Dual Autograph Grading
For cards with two authenticated autographs
Value Bulk
$37.99
per card
~105 days
Max $500
Value
$47.99
per card
~85 days
Max $500
Value Plus
$69.99
per card
~55 days
Max $500
Value Max
$89.99
per card
~45 days
Max $1,000
Regular
$109.99
per card
~35 days
Max $1,500
Express
$204.00
per card
~25 days
Max $2,500
Full Insurance
Super Express
$404.00
per card
~9 days
Max $5,000
Premium Imaging
Walk-Through
$804.00
per card
~9 days
Max $10,000
Premium Imaging
Add-On Services
Prep
Semi-rigid sleeve + one wipe-down before submission
$3/card
Review / Prep
Same as Prep, plus a yes/no consensus on whether the card is worth submitting
$5/card
Full Review + Restore
In-depth evaluation and professional cleaning or restoration work. Pricing depends on the card and condition — ask us at drop-off.
Ask in store
Return Shipping
Rates based on card count and total declared value · Collected upfront
| Cards | Under $500 | $500 – $5k | $5k – $25k | $25k+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 – 8 cards | $18 – $22 | $27 – $34 | $34 – $52 | $85 |
| 9 – 20 cards | $21 – $26 | $31 – $37 | $37 – $55 | $88 |
| 21 – 50 cards | $26 – $29 | $34 – $40 | $40 – $58 | $92 |
| 51 – 99 cards | $34 – $36 | $40 – $46 | $46 – $64 | $98 |
| 100+ cards | Call or ask in store for a rate | |||
$500 insurance is included with every order. Additional coverage available at $1 per $100 declared value.
How It Works
1
Bring Your Cards In
Drop by the shop. We'll look at condition together and talk through which service tier makes sense for each card.
2
Complete the Submission Form
Fill out one line per card — grader, tier, declared value, and any add-ons. We can also take your submission online.
3
Pay Upfront at Drop-Off
Full amount is due when you leave the cards. We accept cash, card, Venmo, Zelle, and Cash App. You'll receive a submission ID.
4
We Ship to PSA
We package and send your cards directly to PSA. You can track your order at PSAcard.com anytime.
5
Wait for Grades
Turnaround depends on the tier you chose. We'll let you know the moment your order comes back.
6
Pick Up Your Slabs
Your cards return in PSA slabs. Keep them, sell them, or let us make you a purchase offer — no pressure either way.
Sell or Consign Your Graded Cards
Ask about any of these options at drop-off or pickup — completely optional
Cash Offers
We make direct purchase offers on graded cards. Let us know on the submission form and we'll reach out when grades come in.
In-Store Credit
Prefer store credit? We can apply the value of your cards toward anything in the shop — often at a bump over cash value.
eBay & Fanatics Consignment
We list and manage your graded cards on eBay or Fanatics Collect. Talk to staff or fill out the consignment form when your order returns.
In-Store Consignment
Your graded cards go on display in the shop. See our staff or complete the consignment form at pickup to get set up.